[EX0]⇒ Descargar Gratis For All Their Wars are Merry An Examination of Irish Rebel Songs Declan Finn John Konecsni 9781537131290 Books

For All Their Wars are Merry An Examination of Irish Rebel Songs Declan Finn John Konecsni 9781537131290 Books

Download As PDF : For All Their Wars are Merry An Examination of Irish Rebel Songs Declan Finn John Konecsni 9781537131290 Books

For All Their Wars are Merry An Examination of Irish Rebel Songs Declan Finn John Konecsni 9781537131290 Books

While any selection of songs can be debated Finn's seems to be arbitrary to my mind. For example he devotes a good deal of print to 'Bold Robert Emmet' while ignoring other songs from the 1798 era such as 'Roddy McCorley', the melody of which was recycled as 'Sean South', 'The Minstrel Boy', or 'Rising of the Moon'.

Curiously, although there is a long discussion of Sir Roger Casement in 'The Rebels the Bards Forgot' chapter that is reprised in a separate appendix, the author apparently has never heard 'Banna Strand' aka 'The Ballad of Roger Casement' performed by the Wolfe Tones and others.

'The Sniper's Promise' is discussed but is not counterbalanced by 'The Dying Rebel'. That's also reflected by a muddled discussion of rebels versus terrorists. If the PIRA were terrorists, what were the Paras? 35 years later the Brits are still wondering if there should be prosecutions for their role in Bloody Sunday.

Then there was the digression into the Mafia's Greatest Hits that left me puzzled. They lyrics, in both Italian and English did serve to flesh out an otherwise very thin book.


Tags : For All Their Wars are Merry: An Examination of Irish Rebel Songs [Declan Finn, John Konecsni] on Amazon.com. *FREE* shipping on qualifying offers. For all Their Wars Are Merry is an examination of the uses and implications of songs in Irish terrorist organizations such as the IRA and all of their various and sundry splinter factions. Basically,Declan Finn, John Konecsni,For All Their Wars are Merry: An Examination of Irish Rebel Songs,CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform,153713129X,Europe - Ireland,HISTORY Europe Ireland,History,History: World

For All Their Wars are Merry An Examination of Irish Rebel Songs Declan Finn John Konecsni 9781537131290 Books Reviews

it was short and interesting. But he's wrong about a lot. as others have mentioned he seems to be completely oblivious to the song"Banna Strand" which memorializes Roger Casement and he gets Mairéad Farrell's name wrong, calling her "Braid".
For All Their Wars Are Merry An Examination of Irish Rebel Songs is one of those books that makes history interesting and fun. Well for me anyway.

This book was of special interest to me. Besides the family connection, I've always had a fondness for Ireland and it's strange sense of humor. If there is a way to make something fun, the Irish are the ones that know how to do it. Heck, their funerals are rowdy affairs with drinking and merry making.

The main text is relatively short, about 45% of the book. but those pages are packed with interesting facts and observations about the songs created and sung, some for memorial purposes and some for antagonizing the enemy, by the rebel armies and terrorists of Ireland.

Declan's book starts off with the distinctions between the groups who created and used these songs. (Introduction The Limits of Terror - How to Define a Terrorist and a Rebel and Chapter 1 A Brief Hisotry of the Irish Rebel A Sketch of Rebellion)

Then he goes into the songs themselves, putting them into categories and looking at each of the categories individually.

Chapter 2 Heroes and Hatreds Examining Songs of Irish Rebel Heroes

Chapter 3 The Rebels Whom Bards Forgot Rebels Who Were Not Honored

Chapter 4 Dances With Armalites The Rebel Songs of Humor

Chapter 5 Wrap the Flag Around Me, Boys Examining Irish Memorial Songs

Chapter 6 Soldiers and Bombers The Self-Image of the Rebel

Chapter 7 Apologies and Other Oddities The Irish Rebel as Catholic

Finally he compares and contrasts the Irish Rebel Songs with those of the Italian Mafia.

After that is the fun part the lyrics to the songs. There is an extensive appendix with all of the songs. And there's an extensive list of footnotes if you're interested in that sort of thing. Normally I skip footnotes, but in this case, I might not.

Over all fascinating look into a bit of Irish culture.
Declan Finn has put together a well written and unbiased look at both the history of the Irish Rebellions and their music. From the 1500s to present day, it touches on most if not all of the major rebel songs, as well as a lot of the minor ones.
The story of the songs of the Irish rebels. A interesting book with some interesting incites into this music. Worth reading.
What to say about this one? There's some interesting history to take in here, and from a fairly unique angle. The style and prose is a little dry and a little repetitive. And it was cool to be able to look up the songs mentioned on youtube to listen to while reading about them. Though who knows, maybe on a watchlist now for looking up IRA music? Oh well...
While any selection of songs can be debated Finn's seems to be arbitrary to my mind. For example he devotes a good deal of print to 'Bold Robert Emmet' while ignoring other songs from the 1798 era such as 'Roddy McCorley', the melody of which was recycled as 'Sean South', 'The Minstrel Boy', or 'Rising of the Moon'.

Curiously, although there is a long discussion of Sir Roger Casement in 'The Rebels the Bards Forgot' chapter that is reprised in a separate appendix, the author apparently has never heard 'Banna Strand' aka 'The Ballad of Roger Casement' performed by the Wolfe Tones and others.

'The Sniper's Promise' is discussed but is not counterbalanced by 'The Dying Rebel'. That's also reflected by a muddled discussion of rebels versus terrorists. If the PIRA were terrorists, what were the Paras? 35 years later the Brits are still wondering if there should be prosecutions for their role in Bloody Sunday.

Then there was the digression into the Mafia's Greatest Hits that left me puzzled. They lyrics, in both Italian and English did serve to flesh out an otherwise very thin book.